State of AI Visibility:
New York Overview
Comprehensive algorithmic audit across all trade verticals statewide.
We analyzed 3,539 businesses across New York. The findings reveal a critical digital divide: 86% of businesses remain invisible to AI assistants like ChatGPT, Perplexity, and AI-augmented search engines.
Only 1% of the market reaches "AI-Ready" status—the minimum threshold required to appear in AI-generated recommendations. Plumbers lead with 5% compliance, while HVAC-R lag critically at just 0%.
This disparity represents an immediate opportunity for businesses ready to act.
Trade Landscape
Trade-by-Trade Disparities
Our analysis spans 9 trade verticals across the state. The radar chart visualizes performance gaps between industries.
Plumbers currently show the highest average score at 42/100, with 5% of businesses reaching AI-Ready status.
HVAC-R show the lowest average score at 32/100, a 10-point gap. 0% of businesses in this sector reach AI-Ready status.
This data represents a market snapshot. Score differences may reflect industry maturity, sample size, or sector norms.
AI Visibility by Trade
Average score indicates relative AI visibility by trade
Leaders vs Laggards
Click a trade to view the full report
The Complete Picture
The Gap Between Web Presence and AI Visibility
The table below reveals a troubling reality: 100% of businesses have a website, yet only 14% use Schema.org markup—the technology that enables AI to understand and recommend a business.
This 86-point gap represents businesses that invested in their online presence but remain invisible to new search interfaces. It's like having a storefront with no sign.
- Avg Score: composite indicator including reviews, Schema, and technical signals
- AI-Ready %: businesses above the 75/100 threshold
- Competition: market saturation level in that sector
This table contains detailed data best viewed on a larger screen. Please switch to desktop to view.
| Trade | Businesses | Avg Score | AI-Ready | Website | Schema | Competition | Top Performer | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plumbers | 166 | 42 | 5% | 100% | 17% | Medium | Roto-Rooter Plumbing & Water Cleanup 89/100 | |
| Electricians | 135 | 41 | 0% | 100% | 15% | Medium | Trimmer Electric 66/100 | |
| HVAC | 172 | 40 | 1% | 100% | 16% | Medium | Reimer Heating, Cooling & Plumbing 86/100 | |
| Roofers | 226 | 39 | 1% | 100% | 20% | Medium | ProLine Roofing 85/100 | |
| Painters | 13 | 38 | 0% | 100% | 15% | Low | Paint716 LLC 67/100 | |
| Landscapers | 303 | 38 | 0% | 100% | 10% | Medium | Buffalo Lawn & Pest Services 84/100 | |
| General Contractors | 251 | 34 | 0% | 100% | 6% | Medium | Catalano Contracting, Inc. 66/100 | |
| Foundation | 76 | 41 | 0% | 100% | 14% | Medium | Real Help Decorative Concrete 66/100 | |
| HVAC-R | 1 | 32 | 0% | 100% | 0% | Low | Sparks Electric Refrigeration 32/100 |
Score Distribution
What the Distribution Reveals
The market median score is 37/100, with an average of 36. This skewed bell curve shows that 23% of businesses fall below the median.
Green bars (scores 81-100) represent "AI-Ready" businesses—those appearing regularly in AI recommendations. Red bars (0-20) show businesses that are completely invisible.
Strategic Implications
- Reaching the top 20% means dramatically higher visibility
- Each 10-point increment significantly improves recommendation rates
- The majority of the market remains vulnerable to disruption by optimized competitors
Score Distribution
The Performance Gap
The Visibility Snowball Effect
The gap between top performers and the rest is striking—and it's widening.
The Top 10% average a score of 67 compared to just 25 for the bottom half of the market. This 42-point gap translates to massive visibility differences.
The Review Multiplier
Even more telling: leaders accumulate 43.1x more reviews than their competitors. Reviews generate trust, trust generates clicks, clicks generate more reviews. It's a virtuous cycle for some, vicious for others.
Businesses in the bottom 50% aren't just behind—they're actively becoming less visible every day relative to the competition.
Reviews & Visibility
The Score-Review Correlation
Each dot represents a business, colored by trade vertical. The scatter plot reveals a clear correlation: more reviews generally mean higher scores.
Three Distinct Zones
-
Upper-right quadrant (high score, many reviews): These businesses dominate AI responses and capture the majority of new customers.
-
Middle zone: Businesses with potential but limited visibility. A modest investment could propel them to the top.
-
Lower-left quadrant: Virtually invisible. These businesses depend entirely on word-of-mouth and existing customers.
Score vs Review Volume
City Rankings
Geographic Ranking
Below: the top 10 cities and bottom 5 cities in New York by average AI visibility score.
Ransomville leads with a score of 51/100 across 5 businesses analyzed.
Queens Village shows the lowest average at 12/100, a 39-point gap from the leader.
What This Means
- Low-scoring markets represent a differentiation opportunity for local businesses willing to invest in their visibility.
- A 39+ point spread between cities suggests significant regional variation in digital adoption.
Geography isn't destiny. A well-optimized business in a "weak" market can easily outperform competitors from major cities.
Know a contractor?
99% of New York contractors are invisible to AI. Send them this report before their competitors find it.
Stop Being Invisible
Join the 1% of New York contractors who are AI-ready
Money-back guarantee
Stay Informed
Receive quarterly market updates and new AI visibility strategies.